نه مخالف نیستن. اصلا کسی مخالف نیست حتی ای‌جی هوگ هم نمیشه گفت مخالفه (میگه گرامر رو ناخودآگاه یاد بگیریم). بلکه بحث این هست که اینهمه تاکید روی گرامر غیر طبیعیه. و روش کتابی هم میتونه با روشهای عملی تری مثل یاد گرفتن گرامر در متن یا با استفاده از POV ها بهتر و جذابتر بشه.
فکر کنم از همه بهتر Benny Lewis این قضیه رو قشنگتر روشن کرده:
My good rule of thumb for many people is to start with phrasebooks, continue learning and constantly practising despite speaking badly, and when you are somewhat familiar with the language and how it sounds, then when you go look at grammar books, they are actually interesting!
که در ادامه میگه:
Seriously – you see the rule explained for something you’ve heard hundreds of times already and suddenly think to yourself so that’s why they say it that way!! When grammar has something to attach to, then it starts to really become a crucial part of a language.